• PRESS
  • GALLERY
  • CAMPAIGNS
  • VIDEOS
  • SUBSCRIBE
Donate Now
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Biography
  • Bread and Roses TV
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Biography
  • Bread and Roses TV

God: A Human History – a rescue attempt by Reza Aslan

  • Posted by Maryam Namazie
  • On November 23, 2017
  • 1 Comments
  • Reza Aslan

My new piece in The Freethinker.

“Religion scholar” Reza Aslan’s new book, God: A Human History (Bantam Press, £18.99), traces the human relationship with God-types from the Palaeolithic, Greek, and Egyptian eras to the rise of Judaism, Christianity and Islam.

Aslan’s history highlights the ongoing compulsion to attribute human characteristics onto Gods over millennia and blames God’s poor image on this “dangerous” humanisation. It’s not God that is jealous or vengeful, he says, but our “nature” and “penchant for violence”.

Luckily for God, Aslan is here to rescue Him.

Gods and religions have caused so much distress that even those who have spent a lifetime apologising for and ignoring the doctrinal foundations of their abuses must make a rescue attempt.

Historically, as documented by Aslan, Gods and religions have been a way of explaining the unexplainable (such as earthquakes or failed hunts). Despite the evidence, however, Aslan says our “brains are hard-wired” for religion and that religion is “inherent” in children. He is a man of faith after all.

But belief in religion or God is not an hard-wired evolutionary trait but more likely a by-product of non-religious functions. Scientist Richard Dawkins uses the example of a moth burning itself on a flame to explain this; the moth does this not because of an evolutionary instinct for suicide but as a by-product of steering via moonlight.

Clearly, God is perceived in the image of man not because of anything inherent in us but because He is man-made. Children believe in God not because they are born believers but because of indoctrination from the day they are born and ongoing physical and psychological abuse such as faith schools, child veiling and gender segregation deemed acceptable only because of religion’s privileged position in all societies.

That religions and Gods still hold sway in the 21st century despite advances in science is simply because of their continued usefulness in maintaining class, gender and social inequalities and injustices and suppressing our dreams and our hopes for a better life in the here and now.

Religions and Gods persist because they remain the best tools of the powerful to control the uncontrollable, including “disobedient” women and children. This is the crux of why God still sells books and makes fortunes – even though there is no God (la ilaha لَا إِلٰهَ).

Aslan’s book is naturally brief (the footnotes are similar in length to the entire book). It has to be given his inclination to erase the murder and mayhem carried out in God’s name and his sanitisation of religion as mere “language” and a “set of symbols and metaphors”.

And as is always the case with Aslan, Islam gets the easiest of passes. The tiny Islam chapter selectively focuses on Sufi-ism; Mohammed, Islam’s prophet, is unrecognisable as a social justice type rather than a war-mongering misogynist.

Aslan’s book ends with a plea for the “dehumanisation” of God and for Pantheism (meaning All is God and God is All). His plea is labelled “bold” and “provocative” by his publishers though it is just another old and tired way of looking at God that is neither bold nor provocative.

In a world drowning in religions and Gods, it is hard-pressed to see how Pantheism will bring “peace amongst religions” and change things for the better as the author promises. Given Aslan’s proclivity for self-promotion, Pantheism will certainly change things for him; he can keep repeating the last lines of his book in a mirror: “You need not fear God. You are God”.

Meanwhile, whilst Aslan re-packages the same old God in order to rescue Him, what will rescue us? Well, certainly not more religions or Gods but rather Laïcité (the separation of religion and the state) and an end to religious indoctrination and abuse of children.

 5

1 Comment

Grace
  • Jul 15 2018
  • Reply
If we're hardwired to believe in God, do I, a non-believer, have a brain defect? I think not.

Leave Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SUBSCRIBE
Upcoming Events
  1. Cambridge University on LGBT Rights, Atheism and Blasphemy

    February 28 @ 7:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  2. Ex-Muslim Women Speak Out on 1st International Atheist Day

    March 23 @ 6:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  3. Days of Atheism, Warsaw

    March 29 - March 31
  4. Panel on identity politics, Rich Mix Cinema

    April 6 @ 4:30 pm - 6:00 pm
  5. Freedom Book Fair

    May 4 @ 8:00 am - May 5 @ 5:00 pm

View All Events

Recent Posts
  • A Landmark Conference for Universal Rights and Secularism and against Fascism
  • Why is Inclusive Mosque so Afraid of Secularism?
  • CEMB march at Pride 2018 in London: A Victory against Islamism
  • Ex-Muslims: A community in protest
  • Pret-A-Patriarchy – on “modest” fashion
Categories
Archives
Latest Tweets

Tweets by @MaryamNamazie

Meta
  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.org

Gender segregation is humiliating and damaging

Previous thumb

Demand for atheism rises in countries under Islamic rule

Next thumb
Scroll
@maryamnamazie

Maryam Namazie
BM Box 1919
London WC1N 3XX
UK

Tel: +44 (0) 7719166731
Email: maryamnamazie@gmail.com
@MaryamNamazie
Tweets by @MaryamNamazie
Tags
Alex Aan Aliaa Magda Elmahdy Amina apostasy atheism atheist Bangladesh blasphemy Bread and Roses CEMB Charlie Hebdo Council of Ex-Muslims Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain Day of Agreement Egypt ex-muslim ex-Muslims execution executions FEMEN Fitnah free expression gender segregation Hamza Kashgari Iran ISIS Islam Islamism Islamist Islamophobia Jesus and Mo Law Society Nude Photo Revolutionary Calendar one law for all Ramadan saudi Arabia Secularism sex apartheid Sharia SSA stoning Tunisia UUK veil women
Copyright @ 2016 Maryam Namazie
 Logo Header Menu
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Biography
  • Bread and Roses TV
  • PRESS
  • GALLERY
  • CAMPAIGNS
  • VIDEOS
  • SUBSCRIBE
This site uses cookies: Find out more.